Showing posts with label William Kirk. Show all posts
Showing posts with label William Kirk. Show all posts

Saturday, April 1, 2017

Probate Records Hint At Family Heartbreak

My day job brought me back to beautiful Salt Lake City this past week.

It should go without saying that I added a day at the end of the trip, so I could visit the genealogy mothership and report for family history research duty.

Family History Library - Salt Lake City, Utah

Exhaustive Search 
I am trying to crack the genealogy enigma that is my fifth great-grandfather Thomas Kirk. In particular, who were his parents and their ancestral origins?

Unfortunately, the existing records for Thomas are pretty spotty. In search of the tiniest of clues, I'm conducting an exhaustive search that includes an examination of the existing records for his children.

I pulled a handful of microfilmed probate records from Crawford County, Illinois - where, in the mid-19th century, at least seven of Thomas' 13 children moved to from Licking County, Ohio. As the minutes until the library's closing time ticked by, I cruised through seemingly endless reels of microfilmed history.

Piecing together family history from endless reels of microfilm.

Coffin and Trimmings
Among my first finds was the probate package for Thomas' son Greenberry Dorsa Kirk who died January 30, 1859. Greenberry, or G.D. as he was called in his estate settlement, was one of Thomas' seven sons who lived to adulthood.

G.D. Kirk's brother, James Kirk, served as the administrator for the estate, and "produced satisfactory evidence to the Court that he had given due legal notice to all persons having claims against said deceased [G.D. Kirk]."

Among the debts "duly established against the estate of G.D. Kirk" were $11 for a "coffin and trimmings" and $55 in medical bills. We know G.D. Kirk died when he was 37 years old, but we do not know the cause of his untimely death. The outstanding medical bills suggest that his cause of death required treatment. Perhaps he suffered an accident or lingering illness, but lived long enough to receive medical attention to the tune of $55.

Itemized debts for G.D. Kirk's estate, including $11 for coffin and trimmings

On February 22, 1862, the estate was finally settled. James Kirk reported that G.D. Kirk's estate was bankrupt and that he had to pay his brother's outstanding debts from his own funds.

"This day comes James Kirk Administrator of G.D. Kirk deceased and makes report as follows to wit that the widow by law obtained all the Estate of said deceased consisting of personal estate only, leaving nothing to pay on 1st class claims, but that he the said Administrator paid the said claims from his own private funds - receipts being herewith filed and the Court being duly advised declare the said estate insolvent and release the Administrator from all further trouble in the premises."

Final settlement of G.D. Kirk's estate and his gravestone (courtesy Larry Boyd)

G.D. Kirk's probate file gives us a small glimpse into what clearly was a difficult financial situation for his widow and children in addition to their already heartbreaking loss of husband and father.

Being Desirous of Settling My Worldly Affairs
I next found the Crawford County, Illinois probate package for Thomas' son William Kirk who died on October 31, 1888.

On January 7, 1889, William's son David Wilson Kirk filed his father's last will and testament with the probate court. The will named David as the executor.

William drew up his will on February 19, 1864, following the deaths of his siblings Rachel in 1852, Hugh in 1856, and Greenberry Dorsa in 1859 - all of whom died intestate.

Perhaps his siblings' untimely deaths and subsequent estate settlements without wills prompted William to proactively make arrangements - while he still had his health and mental faculties - to spare his heirs any unnecessary legal frustration.

William's will begins, "In the name of God amen, I William Kirk of the County of Crawford and State of Illinois being in good health and of sound and disposing mind and memory, and being desirous of settling my worldly affairs while I have strength and capacity do make and publish my last will and testament..."

An excerpt from William Kirk's last will and testament and his gravestone
(photo of stone courtesy of Larry Boyd)

Among William's final requests were that "my just debts and all expenses incurred during my last sickness and for my burial shall be promptly paid by my Executor as soon after my death as the same can concurrently be done." 

Was this request something desired after the insolvency of his brother G.D. Kirk's estate? In the end, William's estate paid out final claims totaling $846 - a sizable amount for the 19th century.

While neither probate package yielded clues about Thomas Kirk's ancestral origins, I did learn about the heartbreak Greenbery Dorsa's family suffered and the effort his brother William undertook to spare his family similar pain. 

Sunday, February 26, 2017

Grandfather's Quasquicentennial

This past Tuesday - February 23rd - marked a milestone: my paternal great-grandfather Samuel Kirk's quasquicentennial.

In the small farming community of Granger, Iowa, Samuel Kirk was born 125 years ago to William and Nancy (Weeks) Kirk. He was the seventh child of a family that would ultimately include 12 children.

Family lore says William moved his brood from Iowa to Edgewater, Colorado in 1901 (censuses and city directories support that claim), positioning two of my ancestors for their fateful encounter.

An Unknown Man
In 1928, Samuel landed a job at a nearby water reservoir where he worked, briefly, as a nightwatchman (a job his own father William held and was killed at in 1919).

The reservoir abutted my great-grandmother's backyard. This job brought my great-grandparents into close proximity and, while never married to each other, eventually led to the conception and birth of my grandfather in 1931.

Persistent family rumors, a suppressed birth certificate, and genetic genealogy countered decades of silence and misinformation to reveal the truth behind a family history mystery: Samuel Kirk was my biological great-grandfather.

What was the nature of Samuel's relationship with my great-grandmother? Did he know he was a father? Did he ever see his son?

I never met my own grandfather - who is now deceased - so I can't ask him these questions. In fact, no one is living who can answer these questions. The players in this drama have passed into history.

Even the historical record - the one published in black and white - would have us keep this secret in perpetuity. Samuel's obituary listed survivors as his wife, a stepson (her child from a previous marriage), and three siblings. There's no mention of his son, my grandfather.

Discovering Samuel 
With no living witnesses and sparse printed history, the nature of Samuel's relationship with my great-grandmother and their son will forever remain veiled in mystery.

Accepting that fate, I move on and sift through surviving records to piece together an understanding of who Samuel was throughout his life. For example, inferring he was a man of service and duty when he was drafted into the Motor Transport Corps during World War I.

More recently, a collection of photos that I received from a distant cousin last year confirmed a strong physical resemblance to my father and his own father. While they say looks can be deceiving, I'll take them in the absence of everything else; anything that provides insight into the shadowy man born 125 years ago.

Samuel Kirk pictured goose hunting at Windsor Reservoir, Colorado

Friday, January 8, 2016

Night Watchman Found Drowned

At 8:00 pm sharp, on a warm Sunday evening in late July 1919, William Kirk - the night watchman at a suburban Denver reservoir - made his hourly report to water company headquarters. It was the last anyone heard from him.

Kirk, who lived a brisk 10-minute walk from the reservoir, had been "employed as a watchman for some time." 

There had been a reservoir at the site since the 1890s. It supplied drinking water to the growing city of Denver, which in 1920 had a population of just over a quarter million people. 

Initially an open air reservoir, the facility was modernized during the 1910s when a concrete floor was installed and a wooden roof built overhead. 

Workers build wooden roof 1914
Photo courtesy of Denver Water

Eventually, the complex was named the Ashland Reservoir and still operates today. 

When William - who was alone - failed to make his 11:00 pm telephone call, headquarters dispatched William Mace, another employee, to check on him. Mace saw Kirk's hat floating on the water's surface beneath the wooden floorboards. He immediately informed his supervisors and collected help from nearby neighbors.

Ashland Reservoir Guardhouse
The police soon arrived and climbed down to the pool's edge, which could only be accessed through steps inside the guardhouse. The Denver Rocky Mountain News offered readers a suspenseful play-by-play.
"The policemen went down this to the tare, which is about twelve feet deep, and poked around with poles until an obstruction was found. The body was then drawn to the surface at about midnight."
After conducting their examination, doctors determined that Kirk had "been dead about three or four hours." He must have fallen into the water shortly after he made his final report to the water company.

The city coroner determined there was no foul play and speculated that Kirk had slipped into the reservoir and drowned. In his assessment, it was an accident and an official coroner's inquest was "unnecessary." The official explanation published on the death certificate was "Accidental drowning."

No autopsy was conducted to determine if there was a contributing factor that may have caused him to slip such as a heart attack.

The following morning, the headlines splashed across the city newspapers told of Kirk's accidental drowning at the age of 68.

Denver Rocky Mountain News and Denver Post headlines 28 July 1919 

His wife and eight children were left to mourn his sudden loss. It was a particularly difficult tragedy following the 1918 death of William's son Thomas who succumbed to the Spanish Influenza pandemic.

William's death created a financial burden for the family since he was the primary provider and died intestate. His widow, Nancy, petitioned the probate court to release to her the funds in his bank account, so she could make ends meet. The court determined that his estate would be divided among each of his heirs.

In probate records, William's children relinquish inheritance
His eight children notified the court that they relinquished their right to an inheritance, and asked that any funds or property be disbursed solely to their mother in "...consideration of her love and affection toward us..."

Among the children signing away their inheritance was my great-grandfather Samuel Kirk.

In a strange twist of fate, Samuel Kirk would land himself a position as watchman at the same Ashland Reservoir in 1928.

Readers of this blog are already familiar with the shenanigans that Kirkguard Sam would get up to with a reservoir neighbor lady (see A Family History Mystery Revealed).

In the late afternoon on Friday, August 1st, my 2nd great-grandfather was buried in Crown Hill Cemetery just a mile west of the reservoir.

His granite marker overlooks the plots for his widow, five of their children including Thomas, and one grandchild.

Walking among the headstones, one would have no idea of William's tragic end just a short distance away.

The quiet shaded spot offers no clues about the sorrowful tragedy nearly 97 years ago.

Tuesday, December 1, 2015

Family Mystery Part IV: DNA Doesn't Lie

A couple years ago, I stumbled onto a non-paternal event after discovering a birth certificate for my paternal grandfather that listed his father as Jimmy Kirk. Jimmy Kirk was not my great-grandfather's name. At least not the name of the man I believed to be my great-grandfather.

Shortly after this discovery, I heard a family rumor that my great-grandmother had a relationship with a man who worked at the water reservoir beside her home. 

I've blogged my way through this mystery. Catch up on all of the sordid details to-date:
I identified Samuel James Kirk as the likely candidate for my biological paternal great-grandfather, but I still needed something more than conjecture, rumor, and hunches to give me solid answers on which I could stake my surname.

Could there be a role for DNA?

Samuel James Kirk was the son of William Frank Kirk. In total, Samuel had ten siblings (six brothers and four sisters). Unfortunately, they're all deceased. To find answers, I would have to move on to the next generation. One of Samuel's brothers had a daughter who is still alive. 

Autosomal DNA Test
I found an address for her, wrote her a letter, and over the course of several months she shared information on her Kirk family history. In November 2014, she agreed to take an autosomal DNA test with Ancestry.com. 


An email finally arrived with the long-awaited news that her results were in; however, it took a full day for her genetic matches to populate. The wait was torture thrilling! 

Her four closest matches were (drum roll, please...) my father, my aunt, my uncle, and myself.

Bingo! DNA had confirmed a winner.

Ancestry.com estimated her relationship to my dad and his siblings as second cousins. In actual fact, they would be first cousins once removed. This relationship prediction aligned exactly how I would expect it to if Samuel James Kirk was my great-grandfather. 

Based on this genetic evidence, I had finally latched onto the correct Kirk family. Great-grandma did indeed have a very friendly relationship with the reservoir watchman!

Y-DNA Test
After the autosomal DNA test connected me to the correct Kirk family, I began mapping out the family tree. I wanted to locate a direct male Kirk descendant to further confirm the initial DNA results. In preparation, both my father and I took Y-DNA tests with FamilyTreeDNA. 

My Kirk genealogy determined that William Frank Kirk was the son of James Kirk (1830 - 1917). James and his wife Hester Griffith had eight children, including James Kirk, Jr. 

Following James Jr.'s descendants, I eventually landed on a male Kirk cousin living in the Midwest. Judging by our family tree, he would be my third cousin once removed. But would the DNA confirm the relationship?


I mailed him a letter explaining my interest in researching the Kirk family tree, and then I asked if he would take a DNA test. (It must be so odd to receive a request like that out of the blue!) He wasn't weirded out.

I received a phone call from the cousin. He was on board. I had a Y-DNA test kit shipped to him and after several months (it took him a while to actually take the test) the sample was at the lab for analysis.

In early July 2015, his results came back. He was a very close match with a genetic distance of 1 (on a fast changing marker) for 67 markers. Based on those results, it was safe to say that we did share a common male ancestor - James Kirk - as the paper trail suggested.

Again, DNA had reinforced the case for my link to the Kirk family.

How Far Can I Go?
While I was waiting for the Y-DNA results to arrive, I continued researching the Kirk family tree. I was able to push the paternal line as far back as the paper trail currently supports. 

The furthest my male Kirk line can be traced is to a man named Thomas Kirk (c.1778 - 1846) who was married to Sarah Louise Bonar and lived in Licking County, Ohio. 

After one non-paternal event, you get a bit skittish and begin to only trust the science. The truth DNA brings to genealogy is both refreshing and a confidence builder in the accuracy of your research. Could I genetically confirm Thomas as my 5th great-grandfather?

I would need to find and test another direct male descendant of one of his sons. Fortunately, Thomas had 12 children. Nine of them were boys. There was no shortage of Y-DNA to track down.

I descend from Thomas' eldest child Vachel Kirk. Zeroing in on Thomas' eighth son Greenberry Dorsa Kirk, I eventually found a direct male descendant who was willing to take a 67-marker Y-DNA test.


In late August, his results came back. He was a close match to my father with a genetic distance of two (the same fast changing marker mentioned above and a slow marker).

The test again reinforced the paper trail: I am a descendant of Thomas Kirk. 

Genetic Genealogy Is Here To Stay
The entire mystery of my grandfather's paternity would not have been solved with any level of confidence without the DNA tests.

Genetic genealogy is now a fundamental tool in the genealogist's toolkit. In fact, DNA will likely play a key role in helping to learn the ancestry of Thomas Kirk and his national origins. 

I look forward to the adventure and my newfound role as a citizen scientist. Now where did I put my lab coat?

Sunday, August 23, 2015

Family Mystery Part III: Are You My Grandpa?

After uncovering an 81 year-old family secret (see A Family History Mystery Revealed) and then identifying that secret's possible protagonist (see Family Mystery Part II: Identifying the Watchman), I set out to learn more about Sam Kirk - the mysterious watchman.

Could I identify clues that would help confirm whether Sam was my biological paternal great-grandfather?

I turned my sleuthing abilities to Sam's life to map out every documented detail. Mindful that any clue could help shed light on this family mystery, no record was too small or insignificant. This would be the definition of an exhaustive search.

Timeline of Sam Kirk's Life
1895 Iowa State Census

  • The 1895 Iowa census is the earliest document I was able to locate for Sam Kirk. His age is given as two years old.
  • He's living in Polk County, Iowa with his parents William F. and Nancy (Weeks) Kirk along with seven siblings.
  • Curiously, both father and son are enumerated by their middle names. William F. Kirk is listed as Frank Kirk and Sam J. Kirk is listed as ... drum roll please ... James S. Kirk. James!
  • Sam's middle name could explain the father's name of Jimmy Kirk that appears on my grandfather's birth certificate. 
  • Now would also be a good time to mention that my grandfather's first name was Frank. Was he named after Sam's father?
  • While this information is not conclusive proof on its own, it's certainly eyebrow-raising and may help tip the scales as we weigh the preponderance of evidence.

James S. Kirk in the 1895 Iowa state census

1900 U.S. Federal Census

  • Sam appears in Grant Township, Dallas County, Iowa. Dallas and Polk counties border each other, so the family didn't travel far between 1895 and 1900.
  • Sam is enumerated as Samuel Kirk and is now seven years old. His birth occurred in February 1893 in Iowa.
  • His parents, William F. and Nancy E. Kirk, have nine other children (ten in total).

Samuel Kirk in the 1900 U.S. federal census

1910 U.S. Federal Census

  • Samuel Kirk is enumerated with his parents living in Edgewater, Jefferson County, Colorado.
  • He's 17 years old, can read and write, but is not attending school. He is now working as a laborer.

Samuel Kirk in the 1910 U.S. federal census

World War I - Draft Registration


  • On June 5, 1917, Samuel James Kirk completes his draft registration card for World War I.
  • His full birth date is listed as February 23, 1893, and he says he is a natural born citizen born in Granger, Iowa.
  • He's employed by John Evert as a bee keeper.
  • He is single with no dependents, and described as short, slender, with blue eyes and black hair.

Samuel Kirk - WWI Draft Registration Card
  • A list of drafted men is published in an issue of the Colorado Transcript on February 14, 1918, indicating that Sam was pulled into service.
Colorado Transcript February 1918
  • His headstone engraving and a list of enlisted men held at the Denver Public Library indicates he served as a Private 1st Class in the Army's Motor Transport Corps.

1920 U.S. Federal Census
  • Samuel Kirk is enumerated living at home with his mother and five siblings. His father is now deceased.
  • He is 26 years old, single, and working as a farm laborer.

Samuel Kirk in the 1920 U.S. federal census

1930 U.S. Federal Census
  • Sam J. Kirk is listed as single at the age of 36.
  • He continues to live at home with his mother and several siblings.
  • He works as a laborer completing odd jobs.
  • This is the year that my grandfather would be conceived. Sam is living in the same neighborhood as my great-grandmother. They live a 2-minute drive or 11-minute walk apart.
Samuel Kirk in the 1930 U.S. federal census

1940 U.S. Federal Census
  • Samuel J. Kirk is living in the same home, but his mother is now deceased. His brother William is the new head of household.
  • Samuel is 47 years old and still single. 
  • He's working as an overseer for the Industrial School for Boys in Golden, Colorado.
Samuel Kirk in the 1940 U.S. federal census

World War II - Draft Registration
  • In 1942, Samuel J. Kirk completes a draft registration card following the outbreak of World War II.
  • For the first time, he's no longer living with his siblings in the Edgewater family home. He's living in Lakewood.
  • He lists Minnie Kirk as the person who will always know his address. This is the first time we see the name of Sam's wife.
Samuel Kirk - World War II Draft Registration
Death
  • Samuel J. Kirk died April 24, 1970 in a military hospital in Fort Lyon, Bent, Colorado. He was buried in the city cemetery in Golden, Colorado.
  • His obituary states that he was a member of the Independent Order of Odd Fellows.
  • His obituary also states that he married Minnie on June 7, 1940. That date would make sense. Sam is single in the 1940 census, which was enumerated on April 1st of that year, but by 1942, Minnie is listed with the Kirk surname on his WWII draft registration card. Curiously, I was not able to locate a marriage record for them in that year. In fact, their civil marriage record is on file with the city of Denver and took place on December 5, 1963. Had they previously been married in the church and were only now - 23 years later - filing that marriage with the state? Perhaps there was a legal need that necessitated the move.
Conclusions
Excepting my grandfather's birth certificate, there is nothing in written record that I've uncovered to-date linking Samuel James Kirk explicitly with his son Frank. 

The documented sketch of Sam's life suggests similarities to the father on the birth certificate: he was a man of the right age, with a middle name that could be construed as the father's, and lived and worked in close proximity to the mother. 

I felt like I was researching the right man, but I wanted proof. I wanted something that could confirm whether Samuel James Kirk was my biological paternal great-grandfather. Perhaps there was a role for DNA to play in confirming a genetic link.